Revue vs. Substack vs. ConvertKit for Paid Memberships

Building a paid membership newsletter is one of the most reliable ways to earn a direct income online today. Writers, creators, and subject experts are skipping traditional publishers and launching independent paid publications. When setting up a subscription publication, choosing the right platform determines how much money you keep, how fast your audience grows, and how much control you have over your business.

Three platform names frequently come up when researching newsletter tools: Substack, ConvertKit, and Revue. Each platform was built with a different philosophy toward content monetization, subscriber management, and creator freedom.

Revue is no longer an active option for creators. Twitter officially shut down the platform in January 2023. Understanding what happened to Revue offers valuable lessons on platform risk and data ownership. Today, the choice for paid membership newsletters comes down to Substack and ConvertKit. This guide breaks down the shutdown of Revue, compares Substack and ConvertKit in detail, and helps you pick the right platform for your goals.

What Happened to Revue?

Revue started as an independent newsletter service designed to help writers publish digests and monetize content. It stood out for its clean editor, simple setup, and affordable pricing structure. In early 2021, Twitter acquired Revue to integrate newsletter publishing directly into social media profiles.

For a period, Revue seemed like a strong competitor in the paid newsletter space. It offered seamless integration with Twitter profiles, allowing followers to subscribe with a single click. It also charged a low 5 percent commission fee on paid memberships, which was half of Substack’s 10 percent rate.

That changed following Twitter’s corporate restructuring in late 2022. Twitter announced the sunset of Revue, and on January 18, 2023, the platform was officially turned off. All creator accounts were closed, and host data was deleted. Creators who relied on Revue had to export their subscriber lists hastily and migrate to alternative platforms.

The downfall of Revue highlights essential rules every newsletter creator must follow:

• Never rely entirely on a single social platform for your core income.
• Regularly export your subscriber list as a backup CSV file.
• Ensure you retain direct ownership of your customer billing records through payment gateways like Stripe.

Understanding these lessons makes evaluating current platforms much easier.

Understanding Substack for Paid Memberships

Substack is a hosted publishing platform designed specifically for writers and journalists. It combines a simple blog website with an email newsletter service and paid membership tools.

Substack operates on a zero-upfront-cost business model. Anyone can sign up, publish free articles, and build an email list without paying a monthly subscription fee.

How Substack Pricing Works

Substack does not charge a monthly subscription fee to host your newsletter. Instead, it takes a flat 10 percent cut of your paid membership revenue.

If you charge $10 per month for a paid membership, Substack takes $1 per subscriber each month. Payment processing is handled through Stripe, which charges standard credit card processing fees of roughly 2.9 percent plus 30 cents per transaction.

This model makes starting virtually risk-free. You pay nothing while building your audience, and Substack only makes money when you make money.

Key Benefits of Substack

• Zero upfront platform costs make it easy to launch without financial risk.
• Built-in discovery features like Substack Notes and cross-publication recommendations help attract new readers.
• Extremely user-friendly interface requiring no technical knowledge or web design skills.
• Automatic handling of subscriber access, gated content, and recurring billing.

Limitations of Substack

• The 10 percent fee becomes very expensive as your subscriber count grows.
• Email automation options are basic, limiting welcome series and subscriber workflows.
• Design options are limited, giving newsletters a standard look similar to other Substack publications.
• Advanced audience segmentation and custom tag tracking are minimal.

Understanding ConvertKit for Paid Memberships

ConvertKit, which has rebranded its core identity to Kit, is an advanced email marketing platform built for professional creators, bloggers, and online entrepreneurs. Unlike Substack, ConvertKit was not built purely as a publishing platform; it is a full-scale marketing engine.

ConvertKit allows creators to build custom sign-up forms, build visual automation funnels, sell digital products, and manage paid recurring newsletter memberships.

How ConvertKit Pricing Works

ConvertKit operates on a tiered monthly subscription model based on your total subscriber count.

ConvertKit offers a free tier for basic email broadcasts. To unlock visual automation sequences and paid membership features, creators subscribe to paid plans starting at around $29 per month for up to 1,000 subscribers. As your subscriber list grows, the monthly fee increases incrementally.

When you sell paid memberships through ConvertKit Commerce, the platform charges a lower transaction fee of 3.5 percent plus 30 cents per sale, alongside Stripe processing fees. Crucially, ConvertKit does not take a 10 percent cut of your overall membership revenue.

Key Benefits of ConvertKit

• Advanced visual automation builders allow for targeted welcome series and custom sales funnels.
• Subscriber tagging and segmentation let you organize readers by interests, engagement, or purchase history.
• Fixed monthly software pricing means higher profit margins as paid membership revenue increases.
• Ability to sell courses, digital downloads, and coaching packages alongside newsletters.

Limitations of ConvertKit

• You must pay a fixed monthly subscription fee regardless of whether your newsletter makes money.
• Steeper learning curve compared to simple publishing platforms.
• Website publishing capabilities are less robust than dedicated blogging platforms.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Features That Matter Most

Comparing these platforms across key areas helps clarify which choice fits your long-term publishing plans.

1. Pricing and Overall Costs

The mathematical difference between Substack and ConvertKit becomes significant as your paid membership scales up.

Suppose you have 100 paid subscribers paying $10 per month. Your total monthly gross revenue is $1,000.

• On Substack, the 10 percent platform cut equals $100 per month ($1,200 per year), plus standard Stripe processing fees.
• On ConvertKit, you pay a fixed plan fee of around $29 to $49 per month, plus ConvertKit’s transaction fee on sales.

Now suppose your newsletter grows to 1,000 paid subscribers paying $10 per month, generating $10,000 in monthly revenue.

• On Substack, the 10 percent platform cut equals $1,000 per month ($12,000 per year).
• On ConvertKit, a plan for 10,000 total subscribers costs around $119 per month ($1,428 per year).

In this higher-volume scenario, ConvertKit saves you over $10,000 per year compared to Substack. For successful creators, flat software fees offer far better margins than revenue-sharing models.

2. Audience Discovery and Growth Tools

Audience discovery is one of the hardest challenges for independent newsletter creators.

Substack excels at built-in discovery. Features like Substack Notes function like a Twitter-style feed where creators post short thoughts and interact with readers. The recommendation feature allows established publications to endorse new writers, driving organic subscriber growth directly within the platform network.

ConvertKit offers its own growth feature called the Creator Network. Creators on ConvertKit can partner with one another to recommend newsletters after new subscribers opt in. While effective, ConvertKit lacks a public discovery feed like Substack Notes, meaning creators must rely more heavily on external marketing channels like social media, blogs, or organic search.

3. Email Automation and Customization

If your goal is to nurture subscribers through automated email series, ConvertKit is the clear leader.

ConvertKit lets you build complex visual funnels. For instance, if a subscriber clicks a specific link in your newsletter, ConvertKit can automatically apply a tag, send a tailored email sequence, and offer a specific discount. This level of customization is invaluable for creators selling online courses or high-ticket products.

Substack keeps email functionality simple. When someone joins your publication, they receive a single customizable welcome email. You can filter emails between free subscribers and paid subscribers, but you cannot set up multi-day onboarding drip sequences based on user actions.

4. Full Ownership and Platform Independence

Data portability is essential when building a long-term media business, as shown by the closure of Revue.

Both Substack and ConvertKit allow you to export your subscriber list as a CSV file at any time. This file includes email addresses, signup dates, and subscription status.

Both platforms also connect with Stripe for payment processing. This means your customer billing tokens belong to your Stripe account. If you ever decide to switch platforms, you can transfer your paying subscribers without forcing them to re-enter their credit card details.

ConvertKit gives you greater control over custom branding, custom domains, and website integration, making your publication feel more like an independent brand rather than a sub-page on a larger platform.

Choosing the Right Platform for Your Content Goals

Your choice between Substack and ConvertKit ultimately depends on your business model, technical comfort level, and monetization plans.

Choose Substack If:

• You are starting a newsletter from scratch with zero budget.
• Your writing IS your main product, and you want to monetize strictly through recurring reading subscriptions.
• You prefer a simple, clean writing experience with zero technical setup.
• You want to leverage network growth tools like Substack Notes and reader recommendations.

Choose ConvertKit If:

• You already have an established audience or alternative revenue streams like digital products and courses.
• You want full control over automated email sequences, landing pages, and subscriber segmentation.
• You generate substantial membership revenue and want to keep more money by paying a flat monthly software fee.
• You want to connect your newsletter directly into a multi-channel online business.

If you want to discover more strategies for growing modern online audiences, check out our guide on YouTube automation category to see how creators combine video content with email list growth. You can also stay informed on current marketing innovations in our technology and AI section.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is Revue still operational for paid newsletters?

No, Revue is no longer operational. Twitter acquired Revue in 2021 and officially shut down the service on January 18, 2023. All user accounts were closed, and data was deleted. Former Revue users have since migrated to platforms like Substack or ConvertKit.

Can I migrate my paid subscribers from Substack to ConvertKit?

Yes, you can migrate paid subscribers between platforms without losing recurring billing. Because both Substack and ConvertKit connect to Stripe, your customer billing information is stored securely in Stripe. You can export your subscriber CSV list and request a Stripe subscription migration through customer support.

Which platform is cheaper if I am just starting out?

Substack is cheaper for absolute beginners because it charges zero upfront monthly fees. You can publish for free indefinitely until you enable paid subscriptions. ConvertKit offers a free plan for basic email broadcasts, but automated sequences and paid commerce features require a monthly subscription once you exceed basic limits.

Does Substack or ConvertKit take a cut of my subscription revenue?

Substack takes a 10 percent platform fee on all paid reader subscriptions, in addition to Stripe payment processing fees. ConvertKit does not take a percentage cut of your overall recurring membership revenue; instead, you pay a fixed monthly subscription fee based on list size, plus standard credit card transaction fees on ConvertKit Commerce sales.

Can I run a blog and a newsletter on the same platform?

Yes, both platforms support public content. Substack acts as a combined blog and newsletter, publishing every post to your public website archive as well as sending it to email inboxes. ConvertKit provides landing pages and creator profiles to host archived posts and sign-up forms, though many creators pair ConvertKit with a dedicated website platform like WordPress.

Final Thoughts

Selecting the ideal platform for paid memberships comes down to balancing growth tools, ease of use, and overall costs. Substack provides the fastest, most accessible entry point for independent writers who want to publish and earn without managing complex technical setups. ConvertKit provides the flexibility, automation power, and profit margins needed by expanding creator businesses.

Understanding the lessons from Revue’s shutdown reminds us that flexibility and list ownership should always come first. Whichever platform you choose, keep regular list backups and maintain direct connections with your audience.

To learn more about our team and publishing mission, visit our about us page. If you have questions or want to collaborate with our publication, feel free to drop us a note through our contact page.

You can also join our growing online community and stay connected with our latest updates across our social channels on Facebook, Instagram, and X (formerly Twitter).